While it’s true that most direct mail ends up in the recycle bin, the advantage of a custom publication is that once in a while your marketing will make its way to the kitchen counter. This can’t be said of postcards, door hangers, brochures, flyers, or hard-selling mailers. So be patient, and be reassured that your direct mail investment goes a lot farther when your method is “show rather than tell” and “hyper-local.”
As the months go by, some homeowners will begin to read your paper. Soon, many will begin looking forward to the next edition. When it comes time to move, homeowners who have received 6 or more mailings (on average) will recognize you, remember you, and associate you with local leadership and success.
Most agents report a break-even after about six mailings. After one year of consistent mailing (bimonthly or more frequently), agents report 150% ROI. After two years, this average jumps to 200% and has been reported as high as 400%, because by that point in your market’s turnover cycle, prospects will have seen enough touch-points to recognize and trust your brand.
Direct mail is a long-range strategy. But with consistent mailing, your custom publication will become a cornerstone of your lead generation and account for a good percentage of your business.